First trial without jury approved (June 18, 2009)
The Court of Appeal has ruled that a criminal trial can take place at Crown Court without a jury for the first time in England and Wales.
 The Lord Chief Justice, Lord Judge, made legal history by agreeing to allow the trial to be heard by a judge alone. It is the first time the power has been used since it came into force in 2007. The case concerns four men accused of an armed robbery at Heathrow Airport in 2004. The judge said jury "tampering" was a "very significant" danger. Lord Judge told the court the cost of the measures needed to protect jurors from potential influence, such as the services of police officers, was too high and that such measures may not properly insulate them. For example, they "did not sufficiently address the potential problem of interference with jurors through their families," Lord Judge said.
'Cash unrecovered'
In addition, it would be "totally unfair" to impose such "additional burdens" on individual jurors, he continued. The trial of the defendants, who cannot be identified, "will take place without a jury in due course", he added. Lord Judge, sitting with Lord Justice Goldring and Mr Justice McCombe, explained the case, which had been brought to trial three previous times, concerned "very serious criminal activity".
It included possession of a firearm with intent to endanger life, possession of a firearm with intent to commit robbery and conspiracy to rob, he said. "The objective of the robbery was something in the region of £10m in sterling and mixed foreign currency," he told the court. But, he went on, the actual proceeds amounted to £1.75m and remain largely unrecovered. Lord Judge described trial by jury as a "hallowed principle" of British justice, but said the Criminal Justice Act 2003 did allow a trial to he heard by a judge alone in certain circumstances.
For the full story from the BBC News website Click Here Click here to return to the News Archive 2 page
|